Changing the Rules
[Note to reader: The author is
English and will not be forced to refer to "English football" as
soccer. So to those of you who consider football to be lots of lycra clad men
chasing a lemon, the term football in this column will always refer to your
definition of soccer.]
EA Sports are unquestionably
one of the biggest Sports gaming development companies in the world. They have
provided us with so many "classic" games that some might say that
they are owed a little competition. And in a way they are right. What is a
genre without competition?
One thing I think they have
always been too successful in is the football genre. FIFA 99 is the best PC
approximation of the "beautiful game" and despite heavy competition
this year from World League Soccer 99 and Actua Soccer 3, it still wins over
the fans with its own unique football medley. The thought behind this article
is that FIFA 99 may be a very good and wholesome PC game, but when compared to
the sport itself, there is no comparison. If you play football, you will
appreciate the difference. That every time the ball is played into feet,
there's a chance that the player receiving will make a hash of it and be
tackled while trying to take control of the ball. If the only football
reference point you had was FIFA 99, you would probably think that the ball
was attracted to the feet of the players... That's not the only thing that EA
Sports would like you to think happens in football.
The question I put to you is,
are EA Sports justified in altering to cosmetic make up of the sport, while
still using many of its great players and stadia?
While writing this article, I
contemplated that question hard and concluded that if EA Sports change the
rules and style of football, they cannot be justified in giving their version
the same name. However, if their licensors, the FIFA governing body, feel that
EA Sports are closely approximating the sport, they are within their rights.
But this whole issue isn't about whether they have the right to call their
game football, but if they providing the average sports fan with what they
were expecting when they shelled out for the newest "football" game
in the EA Sports stable. If you compare both arguments, the latter seems most
sensible.
Surely though, if FIFA are
endorsing FIFA 99 as the definitive football game, then they are endorsing the
opinion given by what EA Sports are distributing, in the same way that Michael
Owen endorses World League Soccer and Alan Shearer endorses Actua Soccer 3.
But player sponsorship is surely different than association with football's
governing body!
It comes back to the issue of a
football definition then does it not? Alan Shearer, Michael Owen and FIFA are
all endorsing a different "version" of football, which creates a
problem within the market. No football game can be the same as another,
because that is simply impractical (and somewhat libellous) so how do we
define the football genre. As a bunch of varying and singularly executed
arcade games which approximate football in some ways and defy it in others?
Until a level of realism is reached in computing that enables total
improbability (ie the possibility that literally anything could happen) we
cannot give a full "simulation" of the sport on this medium. Thanks
for reading.
- Tom |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|
All content copyright
Soccer Gaming, 2000
All marks are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective
owners and are not used under license.
Site design by biglime. Flash by Gateway Design Privacy Statement
|
|