FA Premier League Stars Review
Editors Note: Before you
read this please note that we at Soccer Gaming do like EA Sports. ;-) So does
Salty, but I'm not sure if he liked this game ;-)
Once upon a time, during the Electronic Arts dynasty, a passionate endeavor
was invented. It became known as FIFA soccer. The activity quickly caught the
attention of the growing gaming masses. Thereafter, the legend of FIFA gaming,
which traces its roots back to North America circa 1994, eventually spread to
many lands and peoples throughout the world. Indeed, with each passing year,
the ruling software class at Electronic Arts, the elite EA SPORTS junta,
basked in glory and unprecedented levels of adulation by devising increasingly
sophisticated and fun variations of the activity - all, it is clear to this
day, to the merriment of cyber society. This journal, however, is not about
their many successes. Instead, it is a written record of impressions gathered
during EA SPORTS' one dark, and easily forgotten, chapter: the summer of 1999.
Audience
The underlying idea behind FA Premier League Stars, I suppose, was to attract
the droves of cyber footie fans during the dull summer months while the EA
software giants got ready to unleash their FIFA 2000 installment - now amply
recognized as a watershed moment in the history of sports gaming. The pretext
for the title was to "home in," as it were, on the English
Premiership and the German Bundesliga, two of the top association football
leagues in the world. Given the graphical excellence achieved with each
successive FIFA product, the lack of hype regarding FA Premier League Stars
("FAPLS") and it's German counterpart, Bundesliga Stars, was seen by
some as an indication that this footie game would emphasize terrific gameplay
over all else. The FIFA series, after all, had more than a few detractors who
claimed that it lacked real passion. Purists of the game, the thinking went,
would welcome this offering since it promised a departure from the arcade play
emphasis of the FIFA series juggernaut.
Gameplay
It is clear that FAPLS' gameplay will not inspire the masses. I found this
aspect of the game surprisingly hard to assess, because it did not implement
any particular thing horribly by the standards of antiquity; everything was,
however, consistently mediocre or below 1999 standards. While the game offers
the staple of options - friendly, season, custom league, custom team, and
multiplayer functions - the actual playing experience promptly becomes a
tolling endeavor. The various permutations that I experimented with did not
improve my impression of the game. The controls feel ackward, and the response
time seemed to suffer as well. While the CPU players' reaction was quick, they
seemed to lack any advanced, driving logic. The artificial intelligence,
especially of the CPU goalie, was discernibly at odds with reality. The size
of the pitch was, once again, predictably comparable to FIFA 99 and the other
titles of lesser renown. The goals seem a bit more proportionate here than in
FIFA 99. The ball here, however, apart from displaying a lack of depth, seems
to go out of the pitch at an alarming rate, and with the elegance of a ping
pong volley. Equally annoying is the over-the-shoulder, sideline camera that
is imposed on us during throw-ins. This is stiffness right out of World League
Soccer 99, or the Actua Soccer series, with the Al Gore-like stance and all.
It would be fair to say that I am not a "power bar" enthusiast, and
so I also resented FAPLS' introduction of this gimmick for simple lobs or
shots on goal. As far as I am concerned, the FAPLS power bar only helps to
mask the inferior AI, and does not make up for the deficiencies in the
dimensions of the pitch and the suspect in-play physics. An annoying,
oversized yellow star highlights the players in possession of the ball.
Equally cheesy is the European moonwalk performed by the goalie when he puts
the ball in play. I did find the game's "stars" concept, where your
team's skills are progressively enhanced with each successive win, quite
interesting. The problem is that, win or lose, you may not want to do any
long-term stint in FAPLS.
Visuals
Given the graphical excellence we have come to expect from most EA SPORTS
titles, this aspect of FAPLS truly represents a severe disappointment. Aside
from running what amounts to a pre-FIFA 97 engine, the game implements the
visual panorama in amateurish fashion. Running the game from the comfort of my
decently equipped visual studio - Pentium II, 450MHz, 256 MB RAM, 21"
monitor, and the Voodoo 3 3500 AGP graphics card - the game surprisingly gave
me the sensation of being stranded in a "software-mode only"
dungeon.
It was bad enough that the screen resolutions did not push the EA SPORTS
envelope past the 1024 X 768 paradigm; the game indeed throws us back to pre-FIFA
99 Official Patch days of bread and water - i.e. 640 X 480. Most of us by now
are used to being pampered with at least eight camera angles to choose from.
No such luck here, folks, as FAPLS reduces the menu to a miserly zoom, near,
mid and far configuration palette.
The shocking graphic deficiencies can be summarized with one term: "half
done." Indeed, everything about FAPLS, seems half done. The players all
look the same - chunky, ill-defined buffoons. The stadiums look nothing like
the screenshots released to various game sites in anticipation of the game's
official release. The pitch, in particular, appears extremely grainy and,
contrary to FIFA 99's high-resolution clarity, the FAPLS images give you the
impression of watching a game on a TV without an antenna. Playing at Old
Trattford, the graphic representation of the crowd is also dishearteningly
typical: the "crowd" can perhaps also pass for a patch of Rice
Crispies immersed in Chianti wine. The chalk lines also break off at times,
further lessening the illusion that there's an actual pitch in front of you.
The in-game video sequences seem ripped right off FIFA 99, except that they
flash on the screen faster. I was, after a while, hoping that FIFA 99 would
flash on my screen altogether. The ball, often the nucleus of attention, also
lacks credibility, and has the sensation of being an oversized, floating,
round piece of paper. Need I go on?
Aurals
This was the "best" aspect of FAPLS. If you like some jingle in
between your dribble, the musical selections were excellent, and went well
with the notion of a hip-and-happening footie game to welcome in the
millennium. However, I would not be driven to purchase a footie title for its
musical components, and indeed would do quite well without any melody
altogether. The commentary, on the other hand, displayed phrases seemingly
lifted right from the FIFA 99 oral buffet. The crowd noise at times seemed a
bit more genuine and pronounced than the FIFA 99 variety. Overall, though, the
audible component does not lull one's senses enough to ignore the other
glaring deficiencies of FAPLS.
Solo
This footie game is afflicted with a condition, most prevalent during the pre-FIFA
era, known as fun-deficiency. During play, I found myself consistently
yearning for the comfort, clarity and elegance of FIFA 99. I do not expect to
go back to this FAPLS dungeon unless a massive patch is introduced.
Multiplayer
As in most games, increasing the number of participants tends to increase the
fun. Well, in FAPLS, more players at least contribute to a communal sharing of
the pain.
Fun Factor
There was, I am sad to say, very little electronic enjoyment in this summer of
discontent. I am left with the impression that a conspiratorial wing within EA
SPORTS intended this game as a cynical ploy to enhance the stature of FIFA
2000. I guess we now have an electronic extension of the
"carrot-and-the-stick" theory. My modest expectations would have
been better served simply with an enhanced version of World Cup 98 than this
software stick.
Bottom Line
With F.A. Premier League Stars, EA SPORTS has managed the dubious distinction
of combining the worst aspects of all wannabe software footie games into one
neat, but severely wanting, product. After the NASCAR Revolution fiasco, the
release of this game should have raised some serious questions about whether
EA's quality assurance team was sleep at the wheel. FAPLS represents a
conceptualization crash site of great proportions.
The Questions:
1. Does it advance the genre? As perhaps
Yogi Berra, the NY/NJ Metrostars' newest rumored player sensation, would put
it, "advance it in the backward sense, maybe."
2. Does it offer anything new? Yes, the
"stars" concept is nice, but then the game interferes with this
lofty idea.
3. Does it offer a decent amount of gameplay?
It depends on your idea of decency, but this game is prurient and obscene by
FIFA 99 standards.
4. Is the product relatively bug-free?
Does it really matter? I'd welcome some bugs in exchange for ten minutes of
replay value.
5. Does the documentation thoroughly explain the
game? Well, I certainly didn't see a mention of "sucky"
anywhere, but maybe it was a printing omission.
6. Does this game have any features to keep it from
getting outdated? Well, no, the game was outdated before it went
"gold." It would have been outdated back in 1998.
7. Is the game worth the retail price? NO,
NO, NO
8. Is the game FUN? All this negativity
may well subject me to cyber political exile, so��. �psssst, the answer
starts with "N."
Pros: The "stars" concept is
interesting, but the rest of this program is simply a bad asterisk in gaming
history.
Cons: The "stars" are only
negligible specs in this nasty, brutish and short software sky.
Tips: Buy a piece of history, but wait
till November.
The Score:
1. Gameplay: 30
2. Visuals: 25
3. Aurals: 50
4. Solo: 20
5. Multiplayer: 25
6. Fun Factor: 30
7. Bottom Line: 30
- Humberto
"Salty" Dominguez |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|
All content copyright
Soccer Gaming, 2000
All marks are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective
owners and are not used under license.
Site design by biglime. Flash by Gateway Design Privacy Statement
|
|